What made Google walk off the altar?

Titanium media note:This article comes from WeChat WeChat official account Ginkgo Finance (ID: Three Mornings), author: Guo Yidao, editor: Qin Jian, reproduced by Titanium Media with authorization.
The structure, power and mode of operation of the US Congress are written in Article 1 of the Constitution. As the sole owner of legislative power in the principle of separation of powers, the US Congress is often active in people’s sight. Among them, the most often overlooked is the right of Congress to declare war. Most military strikes in American history have not been approved by Congress, and Congress can only be forced to accept them afterwards. The most well-known are all kinds of congressional hearings.
On April 10 and 11 this year, Zuckerberg appeared on Capitol Hill in a suit and tie to accept the "wheel war" of lawmakers. The cause of the incident was that "Cambridge Analytica Company obtained the data of 87 million users from Facebook through improper means, and used data analysis to accurately advertise to users, affecting the US election." Before the congressional question, Facebook had experienced "public opinion reviled" and "market value plummeted".
That day, Zuckerberg was extremely sharply tortured. "Do I have to give you money so that you can’t disclose my personal information?" However, he can only smile and "play Tai Chi" while constantly apologizing. Even, in order to highlight his "serious attitude", Zuckerberg put a 10 cm cushion on his chair.
For questioning the CEO of a company, the size of members attending the meeting is rare in history. Zuckerberg, who finally came prepared, withstood the biggest challenge in his career, and his share price, which has been "falling endlessly", also rose by more than 4% on the same day. Of course, the risk of data leakage and strict policy supervision are not Facebook’s patents.
Google Pichai(Sundar Pichai was scheduled to attend the US Congress hearing this Wednesday, but due to the state funeral of former US President George W. Bush, the hearing may be postponed until next week. This will be the first time that Pichai has confronted members face to face, because in September this year, neither Pichai nor Larry Pag attended the hearing that Congress asked Facebook, Twitter and Google to attend.
The hearing, organized by the US Senate Intelligence Committee, was about foreign intervention in the US election. The absence of the leaders of Google and its parent company Alphabet made lawmakers think that Google was "very arrogant" and felt extremely disappointed and angry. The relevant person in charge of Congress said: At next week’s hearing, besides the privacy policy, there is also the question of "monopoly".
For technology companies, the more traffic and users there are, the lower the cost and the greater the advantage when obtaining data, and the easier it is to form a data monopoly. At this time, in the event of a leak, the amount of data involved will be huge. With the progress of science and technology and industry, the pillar of information technology — — Sensors are increasingly around us, including mobile phones. This makes data as ubiquitous as oxygen, and it is easier to collect and concentrate these data.
Because of the fear of their own data security, the voice of people’s supervision of monopoly platforms has risen, and in recent years, technology giants have all been overwhelmed. It is an indisputable fact that the internet economy is easy to "win all" and form a monopoly. Li Kaifu, who was born in Google, once said, "The essence of the Internet is monopoly, not competition". Interestingly, Google itself is also the most frequently cited example when people discuss monopoly.
The founders of Tesla, LinkedIn and YouTube are often called big brothers. Their common experience is that they all worked for PayPal, the world’s first e-commerce payment company created by the "Godfather of Silicon Valley". The godfather, the godfather, is also the first angel investor of Facebook, peter teale. In his speech, whenever monopoly is mentioned, Google will be used as an example.
He has a point that "we will not invest in them (former employees of Google)". Because in his view, Google’s greatest success is that it formed a monopoly early and has not faced any challenges for more than a decade. Google employees rarely succeed in starting a business because they think that Google’s success is due to free massage and sushi, corporate culture and smart employees, which will mislead them. The above is Peter’s point of view.

In fact, when I read this passage, I will read our previous article "The Google Gang Made China Rich". I at least agree that some of his views are quite reasonable. For example, the former employees of Google really think that the excellent working environment is one of the reasons for Google’s success; People who once took root in Google did not show the expected special advantages in starting a business after leaving the company.
Peter likes to use Google as an example because in his view, Google’s monopoly is far more thorough than Microsoft’s. And he found that in the early years, the US government’s anti-monopoly investigation always revolved around Microsoft and ignored Google. The EU’s antitrust investigation is more aimed at Google than Microsoft and Apple. In the recent period of time, the plot has indeed reversed, even in the United States, Google is no longer at ease.
Affected by complex internal and external comprehensive factors, the market value of the Big Four in science and technology fluctuated greatly in the fourth quarter of this year. The market values of Apple, Microsoft, Google and Amazon have all changed, among which Microsoft has regained the top, Google has fallen to the bottom, Apple has the biggest decline, and Amazon has the biggest increase. There are frequent commentary articles on these companies, and the focus of this paper lies in Google, which has fallen from the second place to the bottom.
Even if there is a view that Google’s success is because it almost formed a monopoly in 2002, and no enterprise competes with it. But dig deep into the reason, Google’s technical advantage is undeniable.
In Breakfast at Tiffany’s, Hepburn’s masterpiece, the scene of playing and singing Moon River is often regarded as a classic. But there is another scene in the movie that is also impressive: when Paul left Tiffany’s jewelry store with Holly, he went to the library and showed her his published book. Because of the long history, the library uses a very old classified catalogue search based on manpower to find the borrowed books. Every time I see this place, I always think of Yahoo.
The characteristic of the first generation search engine is that it is based on manual classification directory search. The two can form an analogy, because they both classify and store information in a manual or semi-automatic way. Users can get the desired book location or website address by selecting the category and querying step by step. Yahoo is one of the typical representatives.
Yahoo has a long history with Facebook and Google, which we mainly mentioned above. Yahoo once had the opportunity to acquire Google and Facebook, but they all ended in failure because of the price, and were finally far surpassed. There is a saying that in the face of technological crushing, all markets are blue ocean markets. When a new generation of search engines represented by Google came out, Yahoo’s market position collapsed at a touch, melting like ice and snow.
Yahoo’s initial service came from manual editing. Yang Zhiyuan recruited hundreds of employees and catalogued them according to the application of the website. Larry Page and Sergey Brin, who also graduated from Stanford University, have been developing algorithms from the beginning. (Because Larry had a dream that he wanted to download websites all over the world, which could not be achieved manually) Therefore, Google can crawl websites completely automatically. When the scale of the Internet is getting bigger and bigger, the difference between the two methods is magnified.
Later, Larry Page developed a PageRank algorithm to sort rough search results. This algorithm can judge the popularity and importance of a website, so the results of Google search are of high quality. Drawing on the ideas of academic circles, the more times a paper is cited, the more important it is. Because the search results are extremely accurate, the word Google is taken from the technical term in the field of mathematics, that is, 10 to the 100 th power "googol".
Larry was inspired by Tesla to turn ideas and technology into a business empire. There are two recognized prodigies in the scientific community, one is Leonardo da Vinci, and the other is nikola tesla. At the age of 12, Larry read Tesla’s biography and wept for him in the middle of the night. Tesla invented alternating current and radio that flooded the world today, but died in debt in his later years.
In tears, Larry realized that invention alone was not enough. Only by commercializing technology can we change the future and benefit inventors, and Google was born. "Iron Man in Silicon Valley" Musk has also read Tesla’s biography and regarded him as a spiritual idol. Named his company after "Tesla" just to pay tribute to him. Regrettably, in 2018, both companies were somewhat stormy.
Google, which is 20 years old this year, is at the bottom of the four technology giants, which can be described as the inevitable result of internal and external troubles.
It took nearly 50 years to build a media empire, and Murdoch suddenly found that search engines were just like "network parasites" grabbing the fruits of news media. In the name of "free", the valuable content of traditional media is constantly moved to the Internet, which seriously occupies the living space of paper media. In this zero-sum game, Google gains as much as the newspaper industry loses.
In 2009, the economic crisis and the Internet crisis rushed to the news media at the same time, and the global newspaper advertising revenue dropped sharply. As a world media tycoon, Murdoch decided to take the lead in fighting back: charging his news website and blocking Google’s crawling. According to statistics, the total number of hits on its news websites dropped from 192 million to 12 million.

Jobs once said, "We can’t just rely on blogs to meet news needs. We need real reports more than ever. " He cooperated with Murdoch to launch a new product, namely, The Daily, an iPad-based newspaper with no online version. Regarding the product details, Jobs once asked the Apple design team to directly intervene, but in the end he failed to achieve the goal of "iPad to newspapers, just like iPod to music". Jobs made a rare mistake, so Murdoch had to hug Google again.
The media in Germany and Spain have suffered more humiliation than Murdoch. In 2014, they all accused Google of infringement in a similar name and asked it to pay copyright fees. But Google just arrogantly revoked the search results of relevant media, which made their visits plummet and had to beg for mercy from Google. In 2015, the EU launched a formal antitrust investigation against Google.
Google didn’t take the EU’s accusation to heart, and didn’t even hold a press conference. It just sent a blog to respond. It is true that there is no enterprise in Europe that can compete with Google, so Google, which monopolizes the market, is indeed the existence that these Europeans can hardly eliminate with political power. This year, the Russian government also conducted an investigation by the Anti-Monopoly Bureau.
Comparatively speaking, Europeans are more persistent, and have been conducting anti-monopoly investigations on Google for so many years. In July this year, Google and its parent company Alphabet were fined 4.34 billion euros by EU regulators for violating EU anti-monopoly laws, which is the highest monopoly fine in the world so far. The latest news is that the EU is conducting a fourth investigation on Google.
As a "counterattack", Google will charge licensing fees to all Android phone manufacturers that use Google APP services from February next year. Since Android is still a free and open source platform, it has little impact on China where there is no demand for Google APP. However, in the European market, it is quite common for people to use the services provided by Google. In July this year, the EU fined Google $5 billion, which was regarded as the fuse of this charge.
But even if it was fined $5 billion, Google still made a forced profit in the second quarter, with a net profit of $3.195 billion. This is because Google’s advertising revenue in this quarter reached an unprecedented $28.087 billion. Advertising revenue accounts for 86% of Google’s total revenue. In fact, apart from Europe and other regions, Google’s advertising market in the United States alone exceeds the overall size of the entire national advertising market in China.

Mary Meeker, the queen of the Internet, said in her 2017 Internet Trend Report that Google’s market value soared because of the progress of advertising model, that is, grasping the right time and place to promote wide delivery. When the "Prism Gate" broke out, Snowden once posted a tweet warning everyone: "Please don’t use Allo", which was just Google’s communication application system.
Coincidentally, on May 20 this year, a doctoral student at the University of California, Berkeley, posted a blog saying that after he turned off the location function, Google still pushed him an advertisement based on location and questioned that Google was stealing the user’s location. This has caused an uproar in American society, which attaches great importance to privacy. It was not until four months later that Google admitted this, but claimed that it had stopped this practice. But it doesn’t help, except for Europeans, American users no longer fully trust Google.
In recent years, the Indian government has followed the example of the European Union, and this trend was once "infected" to Brazil and Mexico, and Google’s business on a global scale was frequently resisted. Russia has also frequently forced Google to compromise, changing the default search engine for Android users, and the advertising business has made concessions for the "election law." According to Xinhua News Agency, Japan’s anti-monopoly regulator has confirmed that it will launch an investigation on Google next year to determine whether there is any behavior of "exploiting suppliers and suppressing competitors by taking advantage of the dominant position in the industry".
In the end, the US government became one of them. Republican lawmakers criticized Google for deliberately weakening right-wing news, opinions and users’ voices, and Trump also claimed that Google was spreading negative news about its government. It is reported that at the upcoming hearing, Google is likely to be asked about "anti-monopoly".
Murdoch, who was the first to shoot, did not give up and announced his comeback. He is working out a charging plan again, and plans to withdraw his newspaper from Google’s search index after the plan is mature, so as to encourage users to pay for subscriptions.
In addition to the crisis from the outside, the company’s internal distraction this year has also put Google under tremendous pressure. The first thing to bear the brunt is the departure tide of the cloud computing department. In recent months, we have frequently heard the news that female executives of Google Cloud have left their posts. Li Feifei, angel lee and Diane Greene all had high hopes, but they left their posts one after another.
Li Feifei was Li Jia’s tutor when she was a Ph.D. student at Stanford, and both of them had the experience of leading an artificial intelligence research and development team. Li Jia used to work for Snapchat, but when it was about to go public, she listened to Li Feifei’s call and joined Google to co-lead the machine learning department of Google Cloud. In November 2017, they announced the establishment of Google AI China at the Google Developers Conference.
Google AI China, jointly led by two Chinese female scientists, has cheered many Chinese. However, on September and 11th this year, they left one after another, which made the circle of friends brush up, but also made people lose confidence in Google China AI Center. Part of the reason for Li Feifei’s departure may be related to "weapons-grade AI".
She has always emphasized the humanization and ethics of AI, but in an email with other executives, she said: Weaponized AI is one of the most sensitive topics, and I will do everything possible to keep it secret to protect the company’s image. Even if this is not the real reason for her departure, at least it has an impact on her image within Google. It was Diane Greene who announced Li Feifei’s departure at that time.
Greene has been a director of Alphabet since 2012. After his startup was acquired by Google, Pichai personally appointed him as the head of Google Cloud. Pichai joined the board of directors only in 2017, but has worked for Google for 14 years and served as CEO of Google. When they disagree, it is difficult for one of them to give in quickly, so they are often deadlocked.

In 2004, apart from successfully logging in to NYSE, Google’s biggest gain was to recruit Indian guy Pichai. Pichai, who is very popular within the company, is one of the important heroes of Google’s transformation and has led the development of Chrome browser and Android system. But in the development direction of Google Cloud, there are differences between Pichai and Greene.
In previous articles, we mentioned that Google engineers often have an idea: the direction of product development, never listen to the needs of users. Because users don’t know the future, you can only lead the future. This is the bitter fruit of Google’s always taking developers as the center. The products created are very useful, but they can’t satisfy customers and users. Some former employees said that Google Cloud is seriously out of touch with customers.
Larry, the founder of Google, once thanked Google’s engineers for creating first-class products, and also thanked the sales staff for "recovering the money". One of Greene’s missions is to break this tradition. Therefore, she personally set up her own sales team, which is responsible for the sales of cloud software independently of the advertising sales business, so as to strengthen the information exchange between development and demand. However, according to media reports and informed sources, Pichai and Greene have serious differences on projects related to the Ministry of National Defense, that is, the "military AI" project mentioned in Li Feifei above.
This contract with the Ministry of National Defense, known as "Maven Project", met with a lot of protests inside and outside the company once it was exposed. After a short period of fermentation, more than 4,000 employees signed an internal petition asking Google to quit the project. Pichai wants to listen to the protesters’ opinions, while Greene thinks that the project will help to get better military contracts in the future, regardless of interests.
In the end, Google announced that it would not renew its contract after its expiration in 2019, and withdrew from the bidding of JEDI, the Pentagon’s cloud computing contract. It is reported that this contract may last as long as 10 years and the value is as high as 10 billion US dollars. At the same time, Greene is about to leave her job. In order to make a smooth transition, she will continue to serve as CEO until January next year. But her position on the board of Alphabet will remain.
The recent scandal about "sex" and the large-scale strikes caused by it have made Google’s culture suffer the biggest doubt in 20 years.
In addition to the most interesting news that Andy Rubin, the father of Android, was involved in sexual misconduct, The New York Times also exposed such "scandals" of several Google executives. In response to Andy Rubin, the article reported that Google kept silent about his misconduct and paid a huge sum of $90 million when he left his job.
Pichai responded in an internal email that Google has fired 48 people, including 13 executives, for sexual harassment in the past two years, and no one has received resignation compensation. But he also approved the strike, and more than 20,000 employees took to the streets to protest sexual harassment in the form of a strike. The effect is not bad. Before the strike, some exposed executives resigned early.
But Google’s real crisis, not from the grassroots, but from the top.
Larry used to be the CEO of Google, but in 2001, in order to get investment, he agreed to let Schmidt, an older and experienced CEO. Therefore, when he became CEO of Google again in 2011, he put a lot of time into his work and read many books on management theory. But he soon got bored and turned to research and development. Just like the purpose of establishing Google, it is to gain revenue and study other advanced technologies.
Larry is a man who prefers technology. In the early days of Google’s establishment, he thought that the existence of project managers delayed the work of engineers, so he decided to fire all project managers. Fortunately, the layoffs did not succeed, and all these project managers were transferred to the operation department. Even after that, Google continued to recruit project managers, but Google did form a "black technology" culture that favored technology and engineers.
Since 2013, he has stopped participating in financial reports. After Google’s reorganization, Larry became the CEO of Alphabet, and almost began a semi-retirement life: half of the functions of specific operations were delegated to others, and the functions of R&D and creation were controlled by himself. In this way, he has sufficient resources and time to pursue "future" and "cool" technology. For example, in 1995, he was interested in driverless cars.
Other imaginative but almost unprofitable projects, such as flying cars, robot companies, space travel, biotechnology, Google Glass and energy production, are also promoted by Alphabet Holdings. He funded three companies that only studied unmanned aerial vehicles, and many of these projects ended in failure.
If the loss of some investment is within the ability of large enterprises, the lack of leadership is fatal. In recent years, Larry began to attend academic meetings frequently, but did not attend the hearings required by Congress. In the 20th anniversary of Google’s founding, but at the bottom of the four technology giants, such a leader who often "lives in seclusion on a Caribbean island" is obviously not what investors and employees want.
With the equity held by Larry, he didn’t take the initiative to leave, and no one could remove him from the CEO position. Last week, Google spent another billion dollars to buy a piece of land. In the past two years, they have taken a lot of land, but no one has stepped forward to find Google’s original rhythm.
Former Italian Prime Minister and Chairman of AC Milan once caused public outrage in China because of a joke. He once said after a political rally, "Chinese used to eat babies. Should I give Milan to them?" And repeatedly stressed on other occasions, "this is true." What made him form such a prejudice?
For a long time in the past, I typed "Chinese" in the Google search bar, and in the Lenovo area below, the first line always appeared "Chinese people eat babies".
In 2016, the wrong Lenovo search term was finally deleted by Google after seven years of protests by Chinese American rights groups. In the previous year, Larry reorganized the company in order to expand his business scope. The new company Alphabet is the parent company of Google. He personally served as the CEO of the parent company and the corporate values were adjusted from "Don’t be evil" to "Do the right thing".
Google, which seems to be "not evil", has never stopped doing evil.